While Little Women has been adapted numerous times, Greta Gerwig’s 2019 iteration is seen as one of the best, and a large part of that is thanks to Florence Pugh’s unique portrayal of Amy March. In the classic American novel, written by Louisa May Alcott in the late 1860s, the four young March sisters come of age during the Civil War. While most readers embrace Jo, the second-eldest sister with the fiery temper and dreams of becoming a writer, as the true heroine, youngest sister Amy is universally reviled in the fandom.
However, Gerwig’s adaptation breathed new life into the story by changing the character of Amy, making her a more likable and relatable individual. Pugh’s performance helped make Amy a much more rounded character, and more sympathetic. She showed how the youngest March sister could be petty in her actions, but also had a good heart underneath.
In the book, Amy’s bratulence is a major reason for reader dislike, particularly when she burns Jo’s manuscripts as revenge for a perceived slight. Many fans of the book also hated the fact that Laurie married Amy instead of Jo, as it seemed like a consolation prize. However, the movie changes the story by having the sisters all grow up early in the film, allowing the audience to see how they have evolved. This nuance makes their characters more believable and relatable.
Gerwig’s adaptation also allows Amy to grow up more as a person. In the book, Amy initially wants to marry Fred Vaughn for his wealth, but in the film, she gives a feminist speech about the unfair expectations placed on women to marry rich. This added depth to the character, making her a more well-rounded and interesting individual.
Compared to other film adaptations, Pugh’s Amy is a huge improvement. While she still wants nice things and has big dreams, they are presented in a way that doesn’t make her seem shallow and greedy. Her performance was even nominated for an Academy Award, making her a standout in her role. Overall, Gerwig’s adaptation of Little Women is a must-watch, thanks to its well-rounded characters, nuanced storytelling, and Pugh’s impressive performance as Amy March.