Patrick Mahomes and Jalen Hurts: The Unlikely Franchise Quarterbacks
Patrick Mahomes and Jalen Hurts were not universally hailed as franchise quarterbacks during their pre-draft processes. However, the duo is now enjoying a Super Bowl LIX rematch, having compiled impressive 89-23 and 46-20 career records as starters, respectively. Their success has rewritten the NFL record book as spectacular playmakers with unique playing styles.
As a longtime NFL scout, their achievements have changed my perspective on the position and what it takes to succeed in the ultra-competitive league. Despite the flaws that overshadowed their evaluations, Mahomes and Hurts have flourished due to their respective coaches’ willingness to adapt their schemes to their QB1’s talents.
Mahomes’ pre-draft process was marked by concerns over his ability to manage the game and turnovers, but his talent and fearlessness led to comparisons to Jay Cutler. Andy Reid’s time nurturing Brett Favre into a three-time MVP convinced him he could transform a raw, improvisational wizard into an unstoppable touchdown machine, making the Kansas City Chiefs’ big swing to acquire Mahomes in the 2017 draft.
Hurts, on the other hand, was considered a potential franchise quarterback with unrefined pocket passing skills, drawing comparisons to a young Dak Prescott. However, Nick Sirianni’s Eagles staff adapted their playbook to accentuate Hurts’ talents, featuring collegiate concepts, RPOs, and designed quarterback runs.
Their success has ushered in a new era in the NFL, where quarterbacks with unconventional games are dominating. Mahomes and Hurts join Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, and Jayden Daniels as dual-threat playmakers with winning pedigrees. Their adaptability has been key to their success, and their coaches’ willingness to think outside the box has allowed them to thrive.
The duo’s achievements demonstrate that the league is now more open to accommodating unique quarterback styles, and their success will continue to shape the position in the years to come.
